Ethical Dilemma free essay sample

However, Jack has started to do unethical things to the company because he gets rejected the partner position. He cannot stand that the company did not appreciate what he has devoted to the company; therefore, he has begun to download the company accounting software for his personal use and has earned extra money from an outside client. Carla cannot ignore what Jack has done to the company, and at the same time, not only can she not find the evidence of what he has done but also it is hard for her to betray Jack and reveal everything to the company. In addition, Jack is Carla’s boss, so she is aware of that she will lose her job if she reports Jack’s actions to the company. First of all, both Jack and Carla have quality educations. Both of them are enter Aker amp; Aker accounting firm after they graduated and they all spend lots of time on work but they have different behaviors when dealing with pressure. Jack tries rationalizing his behavior by thinking that what he has done will not hurt the company. In the stage 3, Jack knows exactly what he has done is good or bad, but he thinks all he wants is to earn extra money, so he download the program only for his own use, not steals any customer list from the company. Therefore, when Carla questioned him about the truth, Jack did not hide anything but told Carla exactly of what he is doing right now. On the other hand, Carla has more of a struggle than Jack because in her own stage 3, she knows what Jack has done is not right but she still believes Jack is a good person. In addition, Carla spends her free time in volunteering at her church. Secondly, Jack and Carla are suffering from atomism. Both Jack and Carla have families and they both have bills to pay. Jack is under money pressure and Carla just bought a new house. In his stage 5, Jack changed himself to another person because he is overwhelm by being rejected in his attempts become a business partner in the company. Stress make him made mistakes, Jack even considering opening an accounting firm of his own because he is really disappointed about what the company has done to him. Making money has become his priority, and he has tried to convinced Carla what he has done is for his child and medical care. In Carla part, she is also overwhelming in the stage 5 because she thinks it is her responsibility inform the company what Jack has done but she is driven by fear and aware the consequence of informing could make her lost her job. The risk could force her not to step up out and speak to the company. Thirdly, in framing, every significant word evokes that frame. When Jack learned he had been â€Å"rejected,† he immediately wanted to do something against the company. His emotions are increasing in intensity more than ever: suddenly a good person had been transformed into another person and he has made mistakes. Jack think he is the person who does more to make this company a success than anyone else. In the beginning Jack was a hard worker in the company but when things went wrong, his behavior is changing. In Jack’s stage 3, he is angry and blamed company. Also, in stage 4 he thinks that what he has done to the company is right. Finally, in the stage 5, Jack even wants to convince Carla what he did is right, and Carla is doing the same thing as he did because Carla will use the office copy machine to print the flyer for the church. Fourth, between Jack’s and Carla’s dialogue, it is not hard to see that they are not only colleagues, but also friends. Especially, when Jack said he is considering opening his own accounting firm after six months and Carla respond him do not be naive. Carla knows that is not what Jack wants to do, if Jack is getting promotion right now the consequences would be change. Also, she does not want Jack kicked out of the company because she maybe cannot have this job too. Sometimes when a company wants to protect its own reputation, it is necessary to let both of them leave. Fifth, in the ethical theories â€Å"Duty-Ross,† Jack thinks what he did is non-maleficence. He does not think download software could be a problem because he did not steal any customer or confidential information’s from the company; all he wants is to use this software so he can have more clients outside the company. Jack thinks his behavior did not harm the company, but the company hurt him badly. Jack is very emotion right now because he is between stages 5 to stage 6, he cares about other people’s world view more than he do. He do not want Carla think what he did is wrong, and he values to the company is changing. The most important values in the company is the trust between employers to employee once the belief is broken, then the employee will lost the trust to the company. Last but not least, many things could be avoid in this case. As we know atomistic company only shareholder’s make money, conversely in holistic company the success company make employer happy and work hard. Even Jack did such things to the company; it is not all his fault. The company should take half of the responsibility, maybe they are not treated those employees that well so made employee wants to earn more money outside the company. Also, each company should have whistler-blower protection, why is Carla afraid of losing her jobs if she tell the company. She should not worry about telling to the company if the company is protection those whistler-blowers it could help the company become more beneficial improvement. Unless the company do not care about it, all they wants is profit so this kind of unprotecting stop Carla to do the right things. From this case, Aker amp; Aker accounting firm is more an atomistic company, because they should know how Jack feel when he got rejected and it is important for the company to comfort those employees who did not get promotion, but there is no evidence show the company ever try comfort Jack’s angry.